A 79 year old male with a past medical history of hyperlipidemia, hypertension, and prediabetes presented for eight days of generalized malaise, nausea, facial diplegia, and ascending weakness in the bilateral lower extremities. The patient also endorsed significant social stressors resulting in feelings of depression, anhedonia, increased sleepiness, and decreased energy, concentration, and appetite. Physical exam, CBC, BMP, EKG and CXR were unremarkable on presentation. Ferritin was elevated. The patient then developed new dysarthria and dysphagia. CT and MRI imaging revealed an acute right PICA stroke, which did not explain the patient's initial presentation. A lumbar puncture was done and revealed albuminocytologic dissociation favoring a variant of Guillain Barre, so plasmapheresis was initiated. Later in the course, WNV antibodies were found in the cerebrospinal fluid. The patient improved with plasmapheresis and was discharged to inpatient rehabilitation.